Every year, we ask our readers to nominate and vote for their favorite local businesses in Manhattan. The winner of our annual award for Best Bartender in Manhattan has been chosen, and we’re excited to share the results with you. Find out which master mixologist our readers picked as the best bartender in the city!
2024: Manhattan Voted Paddy Reilly’s Music Bar Best Bartender!
Paddy Reilly’s Music Bar
519 2nd Ave
(212) 686-1210 – paddyreillysmusicbar.us
From Sam Malone of Cheers to Moe Szyslak of The Simpsons, bartenders can certainly be one-of-a-kind characters. It could be because of their overall demeanor. Or perhaps it’s how they pour their drinks. Either way they can set the tone and atmosphere for your whole night out. Since 1986, Paddy Reilly’s Music Bar has been known as the best Irish bar in the city. And part of that is a nod to their awesome bartenders. Whether pouring a basic Guinness or crafting that perfect cocktail, the bartenders at Paddy Reilly’s are as popular as the live music you’ll find at this iconic Irish bar.
2023: Manhattan Voted Dear Irving on Hudson Best Bartender!
Dear Irving on Hudson
310 W 40th St
(212) 533-4466 – dearirving.com
Located on the 40th and 41st floor overlooking the bright lights of the city, the only thing that matches the atmosphere at Dear Irving on Hudson is the friendly and professional bartenders. With a warm smile and a deep knowledge of their craft, you’ll be right at home at this outstanding establishment. Whether you’re an aficionado who knows exactly what you want, and you’re looking for a mixologist who knows how to please, or you’re just a newcomer to the scene looking to be taken on a trip through all the alcohol industry has to offer, the staff at Dear Irving on Hudson will have you covered! An afternoon stop for a drink, or a big night out — you’ll find what you need here. Swanky purple couches, turquoise bar stools, diamond decor and fascinating light fixtures, this bar feels like stepping back in time — while also taking a trip to the future at the same time. Head on over and say hello, they’ll be thrilled to meet you!
2022: Manhattan Voted Dear Irving on Hudson Best Bartender!
Dear Irving on Hudson
310 West 40th Street
dearirving.com
Located on the 40th and 41st floor overlooking the bright lights of the city, the only thing that matches the atmosphere at Dear Irving on Hudson is the friendly and professional bartenders. With a warm smile and a deep knowledge of their craft, you’ll be right at home at this outstanding establishment. Whether you’re an aficionado who knows exactly what you want, and you’re looking for a mixologist who knows how to please, or you’re just a newcomer to the scene looking to be taken on a trip through all the alcohol industry has to offer, the staff at Dear Irving on Hudson will have you covered! An afternoon stop for a drink, or a big night out — you’ll find what you need here. Swanky purple couches, turquoise bar stools, diamond decor and fascinating light fixtures, this bar feels like stepping back in time — while also taking a trip to the future at the same time. Head on over and say hello, they’ll be thrilled to meet you!
2021: Manhattan Voted Jack McGarry- The Dead Rabbit Grocery and Grog Best Bartender!
Jack McGarry- The Dead Rabbit Grocery and Grog
30 Water St
(646) 422-7906 – www.deadrabbitnyc.com
Known as a “cocktail virtuoso” and “walking drinks encyclopedia”, Jack McGarry has earned the title of Best Bartender through years of mixing drinks. McGarry began his career in Belfast, where he started bussing tables and soon graduated to bartending in the city’s budding nightlife scene. He then brought his talents to NYC to open the Dead Rabbit, a ground floor pub built on the Irish tradition of hospitality and community. According to reviewers, watching McGarry make their drinks is like a show. Just a few of his must try creations include the Disco Queen — made with white rum, vermouth, ginger and grapefruit — Doctor’s Orders — a concoction of bourbon, cinnimon and vanilla, of course, perfected classics like Irish punch and Irish coffee!
2020: Manhattan Voted The Dead Rabbit Grocery and Grog Best Bartender!
The Dead Rabbit Grocery and Grog
30 Water St
(646) 422-7906 – www.deadrabbitnyc.com
The Dead Rabbit is a great spot for drinks and food. Located in the Financial District, it’s a mix between an Irish Pub and New York cocktail bar. On the first floor, the lively bar is crowded and loud, but it’s part of the charm making for an inviting, warm and friendly atmosphere. The bartenders are experts in mixing and creating drinks. The food is also prepared with care, offering Irish fare, perfect to go with a craft beer, or cocktail. The food and drinks are spectacular with a mix of different tastes and flavors. Be sure to check it out if you’re looking to have a wonderful night out in the city.
