The search for Manhattan’s best cigar shop for New Yorkers is over! We asked New Yorkers to vote for their favorite, and the winner is finally revealed. Find out which shops offers an extensive selection of cigars on Best of the City.
2024: Manhattan Voted Casa de Montecristo Best Cigar Shop!
Casa de Montecristo
1016 Second Avenue
(212) 750-0809 – casademontecristo.com
The aroma is fetching at Casa de Montecristo. This is a very fine place for cigar lovers with good selections and friendly service. The lounge impresses newbies and connoisseurs alike, prices are fair, and the spot is a haven for a break from your routine and is sure to become a must-go place when you’re in the neighborhood. Some call it super chill and others comment it’s the kind of place to learn what you like to smoke with thorough guidance. You will truly love going into this Second Avenue business and will definitely go back with friends anytime you’re visiting New York City. The vibe is plush, engaging, friendly and welcoming. The varied selection of premium cigars is unmatched in the area. The selection is of premium quality. Take yourself into a cigar lounge that makes you feel like you stepped into a friend’s home.
2023: Manhattan Voted 97 Tobacco Shop Best Cigar Shop!
97 Tobacco Shop
2578 Broadway
(646) 649-2027 – 97tobaccoshop.wixsite.com/website
A sweet, smoky aroma entices you into 97 Tobacco Shop. The cigar shop is staffed by people who have extensive knowledge of cigars from around the world and are happy to share it with customers. This great little cigar shop will become your place when it’s time for the utter delight of walking into a cigar shop to peruse premium products whether random from an unknown city, or want to smoke one you love and can’t find anywhere else. Be mesmerized by the olfactory sensations here. Discover new cigars and meet new friends for life.
2022: Manhattan Voted 97 Tobacco Shop Best Cigar Shop!
97 Tobacco Shop
2578 Broadway
(646) 649-2027 – 97tobaccoshop.wixsite.com/website
A fan of a nice smoke? Look no further than 97 Tobacco Shop on Manhattan’s West Side. Founded in 2000, they’ve brought the best ingredients anyone can offer, and have tons of satisfied customers to prove it. With a deeply knowledgeable staff who have years of experience curating everything you could ask for, your every question will be answered — and you’ll know you found your new go-to from the moment you enter the shop. And on top of their great tobacco products, they also boast a huge selection of paraphilia that will meet your every need! The store is open seven days a week, so come on in, pick your cigar and take a puff to end a long week! Other cigar sellers can’t hold a candle to 97 Tobacco Shop!
2021: Manhattan Voted Mulberry Street Cigar Co. Best Cigar Shop!
Mulberry Street Cigar Co.
140 Mulberry St
(212) 941-7400 – www.mulberrystcigars.com
Other cigar shops can’t hold a candle to Mulberry Street Cigars. All of the products at the Little Italy hand-rolled cigar shop are made fresh daily and wrapped by the best rollers and are sure to please even the snobbiest of cigar smokers. The shop’s selection includes Connecticut shade mild and sweet/mild, Maduro medium and Menza Menz medium. The shop hosts rolling demonstrations every day of the week and during special events like the festival of San Genaro, an annual tradition in Little Italy that takes place in September. The store is open seven days a week, so come on in, pick your cigar and take a puff to end a long week!
2020: Manhattan Voted Mulberry Street Cigar Co. Best Cigar Shop!
Mulberry Street Cigar Co.
140 Mulberry St
(212) 941-7400 – www.mulberrystcigars.com
Other cigar shops can’t hold a candle to Mulberry Street Cigars. All of the products at the Little Italy hand-rolled cigar shop are made fresh daily and wrapped by the best rollers and are sure to please even the snobbiest of cigar smokers. The shop’s selection includes Connecticut shade mild and sweet/mild, Maduro medium and Menza Menz medium. Cigar lengths range from 4.5 to 6.25 inches. The shop hosts rolling demonstrations every day of the week and during special events like the festival of San Genaro, an annual tradition in Little Italy that takes place in September. The store is open seven days a week.
